(AP Photo/Ed Andrieski)
Sometimes Danny says that he doesn't think dogs have the same feelings as humans and they don't hear what we say. I think that dogs and humans have the same feelings and deal with their emotions in the same way. You see and hear a dog crying. You can tell when they are mad, happy, and excited. How could you not think that dogs have feelings and emotions. There is a reason they are man's best friend.
This morning I was watching a story on the news about PTSD and dogs returning from war. This is from the Associated Press website
Gina was a playful 2-year-old German shepherd when she went to Iraq as a highly trained bomb-sniffing dog with the military, conducting door-to-door searches and witnessing all sorts of noisy explosions.
She returned home to Colorado cowering and fearful. When her handlers tried to take her into a building, she would stiffen her legs and resist. Once inside, she would tuck her tail beneath her body and slink along the floor. She would hide under furniture or in a corner to avoid people.
A military veterinarian diagnosed her with post-traumatic stress disorder — a condition that some experts say can afflict dogs just like it does humans.
In the past, a dog showing these signs of PTSD would have been put down. How is that fair? This dog is protecting their country the same way any man or woman is. We don't put humans down. Why is this even an option for dogs?
Gina has been attending therapy and has been re-socialized. Her handler, Staff Sgt. Melinda Miller, says she trusts the dog with her entire life. Gina has returned to active duty status.
This is the part of the story I don't like.
But some veterinarians dislike applying the diagnosis to animals, thinking it demeans servicemen and women, Dodman said. He added that he means no offense to military personnel when he uses the term.
I do not think it should offend military personal by using this term. We have no problem sending dogs onto the front line, and honestly, they have no say in it. But they are serving and protecting our country. They deserve the same honor and respect as any man or woman serving our country.
What are your thoughts on this topic? You can read the entire story here.





I trust my dog with my life. Whenever he hears an explosion or just someone walking up to the door he barks and no matter where he is he comes right to my side and makes sure I know something is wrong but that he's there for me. It's the sweetest thing ever to see. Dogs should never get put down for having ptsd. Dogs save people's lives just like humans do.
ReplyDeleteI wonder why it took them so long to finally recognize PTSD with dogs. Every abused dog shows signs of PTSD and it is crazy that they think it would offend soldiers by using PTSD for dogs. Heck, they can get cancer, just like us, Humans can have HD just like dogs, and they have to drink water, breath the same air just like we do. So why shouldn't they get PTSD too.
ReplyDeleteI believe that my male has it. Just because he was put under so much pressure, stress got beat up the whole time over and over and over again that he developed a fear towards human and was tired of life.
So yes, I believe that dogs can have PTSD... no, I KNOW they can get it, I go as far to say that any living, breathing creature can get PTSD.
I love my dog almost as much (maybe just as much) as my husband! I couldn't imagine seeing him put down for protecting me or my country. Some people look at animals and think they don't have feelings or emotions, they do. When I was sick a few nights ago, Arai was right by my side laying with me, whining and acting as a pillow for me.
ReplyDeletePTSD in animals is probably very hard to treat. They can not express what they are scared of exactly and why. I don't think military personel should be offended by the term and maybe it would help them to see that all sorts of people and animals are experiencing what they are and they could work together to help fight it.
I have read both With Love from Baghdad and also From Baghdad to America: Life Lessons from a Dog Named Lava both are excellent books and a first person view of one Man and his dogs PTSD issues both are authored by Jay Kopelman who is a former lieutenant colonel in the U.S. Marine Corps
ReplyDeleteWe don't have dogs, but I love them so much. I believe they are very much like humans and I believe that we should be ashamed of ourselves for treating them like humans to go on the front lines, but not when they come back from war. It's sad... I didn't read the whole article (trying to get ready for work), but wouldn't it be nice if they had like an adoption something or other for them... just like the greyhounds???
ReplyDeleteI totally agree with you. Dogs respond and feel the same way humans do. Dogs have been beside man ever since the beginning of time. However, the best thing about dogs, is that once they have that loyalty to a human, they would die before breaking that loyalty. Dogs are just furry humans on four legs and they deserve credit for being on the front lines just like humans. I can't even imagine losing my dog and I know I would suffer just as much as if I had lost a friend or relative. Dogs are wonderful creatures and like I said, I think they deserve more credit than they get.
ReplyDeleteWhy would they put down that poor animal because it had PTSD? I completely agree with you. They have no choice in going over there, and they serve our country, and SAVE soldiers. They should most definitely be helped when they come home. I can't even imagine my dog being put down. I agree with Carmen, they're just furry humans with four legs.
ReplyDeleteThanks for posting this!
Nicole, I totally agree with you on this issue. Yes, it takes time to re-socialize the animals, but it can be done. I think Vet's are so quick to put the animals down because they don't think anyone wants to take the time to help them. Remember the Michael Vick dogs? PETA said they should be put down because "they will never be the same." Some of them have already been re-socialized.
ReplyDeleteVery well written.
Dave and I have had the "do dogs have feelings/emotions" debate several times - thank you for posting about this.
ReplyDeletewow... seems like a hot topic to wrap your mind around. No, I do not think dogs are in the same category as humans, and there should be no comparison at all. However, I think they should be treated humane. I think it depends on if the ptsd is seriously effecting their well-being and everyday function. If it is serious enough that the dog is putting itself in danger, then maybe putting the dog down could be an option. If not, I think the dog should go do a loving home or retrained with care.
ReplyDeleteI agree with you COMPLETELY!!! I love animals, they each have their own personalities and feelings. I volunteer at 2 shelters in the area and it is my dream to spend my life helping them. One of the shelters I go to is an equine rescue shelter, almost all of the horses there at one point in their lives were "too far gone to save" according to the veterinarians. Of course they are all doing great now (thanks to the patience and love of the people who work there) and are even being ridden and adopted to new loving families. We are too quick to write off their ability to survive and thrive.
ReplyDeleteGreat post!!
With a husband that has been diagnosed with severe PTSD, I (nor would he) take offense to dogs being diagnosed with PTSD. I've been seeing more and more dogs take on a nurturing roll for Combat Veterans with PSTD. These dogs have become service animals - a part of the Veteran's family. My husband uses our male Rottweiler as his service dog. He takes him EVERYWHERE. I know that if Newman went into combat that my husband would want him to be diagnosed if he was suffering. AND, there's rehabilitation which Newman would get.
ReplyDeleteOn a side note. When police animals (i.e., dogs, horses) get attacked, killed, etc. they are treated much like a human. One of my professor's had her horse punched in the face while patrolling the state fair. The guy that punched her horse had an "assault to a police officer" charge slapped on him.
So, why do some vets/people think diagnosing dogs with PTSD is so wrong?! Simply, they don't understand that when they're in combat they serve too.
I think it is completely likely, I mean my dog needs attention and whines when I ignore him too much. When Anthony and I would fight and I would cry he would curl up in my lap and just lay there because he knew I just needed to feel the weight of something to remember it was going to be okay. I think it's a great article and i fully believe it
ReplyDeleteI totally agree! I believe dogs can have the same emotions as people.
ReplyDeleteI can tell you from Fiona, dogs DEFINITELY suffer trauma! Not like mine have been off to battle or anything, but she definitely has separation anxiety and freaks out when we leave her, and then will bark when we come back until we cuddle her.
ReplyDeleteIt's the same with a dog who is abused! The cower in corners when people come near them, and I had a friend who adopted an abused pit. He was the sweetest dog, but so skidish that even turning a fan on freaked him out.
Dogs definitely have feelings and show them very obviously to us. This story makes me sad kind of. Why would anyone get offended that a dog, helping to protect our service men and women, be diagnosed with psychological problems? Mine are definitely my best friends!
Poor puppy!!! I think it's fine to diagnose dogs with the disorder. Why shouldn't we?? They may not be human but they are living, breathing, feeling beings and should be respected as such. If we are willing to put so much energy and commitment into the training why shouldn't we also do the same for their recovery. Thanks for posting this. I had no idea this was out there!
ReplyDeleteI read about this a couple days ago...it just shows how much war can affect ANY living being. It's so sad to see how difficult that little pooch has it. What a great article that was!
ReplyDeleteI actually read this article the other day on Yahoo. I was really interested in it, because we are adopting an EOD dog, and I'm worried that he could have PTSD too.
ReplyDeleteI can completely understand why these dogs would have PTSD, I mean....they are trained to sniff out, or be around IED's all day long. Of course that is going to affect them!
This is so sad! How awful to punish them with death for having acute emotions. I'm glad she's getting resocialized!
ReplyDeleteI read this on Yahoo! and I seriously almost cried. I felt so terrible that a dog had to experience the same emotions that the other side of the world brings. I'm glad to hear that things are getting better for her though!
ReplyDeleteMy male dog is actually the best example. My parents are very successful German Shepherd breeders. Some of the most successful working sires come out of our line and we were always looking for foster families to raise our dogs, just like the military breeding program does. Many of our shepherds went to the police and the military in the States. There are more dogs from us in the US than in Germany.
ReplyDeleteHowever, my male Yukon was given to a trainer who was supposed to title him in Schutzhund. He was a very promising young dog. The trainer used brutality instead of giving him time and understanding. He was put under so much pressure and stress that he wouldn't go near anyone when he came back. That was the day when my mother decided to never give a dog into training again. She hasn't had a litter since and our dogs are highly demanded. Yukon is six years old now and it took her that long to decide whether she is going to have another litter or not.
My point is, he has PTSD. He showed all the signs and was literally scared from his own shadow. It took him a year to recover. You can see his potential but the PTSD will always be there. It will never go away. It can get triggered anytime and it's not like they can talk about it. They can tell us in their own language.
Another thing I wanted to add. Dogs are NOT Human. Thats the biggest mistake a dog owner can do, to treat them like a human. That is why there are so many obese, aggressive out of control dogs out there.
Dogs can get PTSD, just like Humans. Dogs have feelings, they can be happy, excited, angry or depressed but they are NOT Human.
Dogs have their own pack structures, their own rules and their own way to communicate with us but they are not Humans on four legs.
I have to correct one thing. Zenzy came directly after Yukon. Means there was one more litter but there was a year in between and ever since she didn't have another litter.
ReplyDeleteI'm a few days late but I agree that they have emotions. Move a dog across the country and away from their friends and their depressed. I also don't think its demeaning. Victims of many traumas can have PTSD. We have a K-9 officer in the family and I know that dog loves to work and when he's not working, he's bored. Great post!
ReplyDelete